The respondents were appointed in Group III posts in Subordinate Agricultural Services SAS in the Department of Agriculture in the undivided State of Uttar Pradesh Some of them were appointed ... in and some in the year A provisional seniority list in the cadre of SAS Group III was prepared where they were shown senior to one Madhav Singh Tadagi The said Madhav Singh Tadagi who was working as Agriculture Plant Protection Supervisor Group III was given ad hoc promotion to the post of Assistant Development Officer Plant Protection Group II by the Deputy Director of Agriculture on In the year a Selection Committee was constituted for making promotion to Group II posts on the basis of seniority-cum-fitness from amongst the employees of Group III posts and in the said selection process the respondents as well as Madhav Singh Tadagi were promoted on regular basis in Group II posts After regular promotion was made a seniority list was finalized in respect of promotional cadre and the respondents were shown senior to Madhav Singh Tadagi The final seniority list was issued on